I know, I know. My ability to remain consistent with my posting ebbs and flows. Believe me when I say that it is not my intention. I truly has the best of intentions, but this year, my health has been kicking me in the butt and growing older is no joke. But... you're not here for that.
I’m trying something a little different with this new series, so bear with me! Many of you know Deanna's World for its focus on the publishing industry, writing insights, and book-related topics. Lately, I’ve felt the itch to stretch my writing chops in a new direction and bring some fresh variety to what you find here – something purely for the enjoyment of it.
I’m a member of a wonderfully spirited local book club that gathers monthly at a book cafe in town. We choose a book, and the next month, we unpack it with gusto. The conversations are… well, you’re about to find out!
So, to share a slice of that enjoyment and offer a different flavor of writing from my corner, consider this your invitation. Here’s a look at our (not so) recent, rather animated, discussion…
So It Begins: My Pick, Their Quirks, and First Impressions
Alright, folks, let me set the scene. It was my turn to pick the book, and after much soul-searching (and a secret desire to live vicariously through someone else’s fabulous Italian meals), I chose Stanley Tucci’s "What I Ate In One Year: (and related thoughts)." I was buzzing! This was one of the few books I’d actually committed to reading physically, well, electronically. I got the Kindle version—a rare event for this audiobook-loving recapper—and I’d been savoring it, one diary entry at a time, for the better part of six months. I was about 70% through by the time our meeting rolled around (don’t judge, life happens!), but I was already a full-blown Tucci convert. Pasta was my new religion, and his food documentaries were my sermons.
So, picture it: "The Daily Grind," our beloved (and very forgiving) café. "Gary," bless his caffeinated heart, already had a fresh batch of something almond-y and delightful wafting from the oven—probably sensing we’d need the sustenance.
"Brenda," our resident must-read-everything-ever-published guru, was practically vibrating. "Oh, Stanley Tucci!" she trilled before I even sat down. "I read 'Taste' last year, of course, and then I re-read it in preparation for this, and I also found a fascinating article about his childhood culinary influences and an interview where he discusses his favorite olive oils. You simply must delve into his entire oeuvre to truly appreciate the nuances!" (Yes, Brenda, we know. You’re always three steps ahead and slightly insufferable about it, but we love you anyway. Mostly.)
Across the table, "Chad" already had that glint in his eye. You know the one. The "I’m about to disagree with everyone and everything, and you will all eventually see the undeniable truth of my argument" glint. This was going to be good.
"Agnes" arrived, "Fido" yipping suspiciously from his tartan carrier. "Well," she announced, settling in, "I saw his picture on the cover. He looks like a nice enough young man. But Fido didn't like the sound of the pages turning. Too rustly." Standard Agnes.
"Mildred," bless her, peered at the book I placed on the table. "Stanley... Toochy? Is he related to that nice weatherman on channel seven?"
"Eleanor," meanwhile, was attempting to subtly (and failing) adjust her skirt, giving us all a bit more of a show than we bargained for with our coffee. "Food, is it?" she mumbled. "My Muffin (that’s her prize-winning Persian, not an actual muffin) is terribly picky. Only eats the salmon paté, you know. Not the tuna." This, I felt, was a premonition.
"Reginald," our connoisseur of convoluted critiques, sniffed disdainfully as he surveyed the cover. "Ah, yes. The Tucci. An… epicurean memoir, I presume? One hopes the prose transcends mere gastronomic cataloging." (Spoiler: Reginald was not impressed. At all.)
"Jenny," our esteemed English teacher, had her copy bristling with little sticky notes. "The diary format is an interesting narrative choice," she began, "allowing for an episodic exploration of themes rather than a traditional linear progression. As an English teacher, I find that structurally quite compelling." (Yes, Jenny, we know you’re an English teacher.)
"Valerie," our local author, nodded thoughtfully. "It’s a challenge, writing about something as personal as daily food. Making the mundane engaging takes skill." "Mike," our radio voice, cheerfully admitted he hadn't gotten past the introduction but had heard Tucci’s voice was very soothing on a podcast once. Typical Mike. And "Chloe," our stay-at-home mum, was just hoping for some good food-related gossip she could relate to picky toddlers.
So, What Did Stanley Actually Eat? (And What Did We Think He Was Thinking?)
I kicked things off, still basking in my Tucci-induced glow. "Okay, so it’s basically his food diary for a year, right? Meals at home, on set, fancy restaurants, simple stuff... and all his little thoughts and memories tied to it."
The book, for those who haven’t yet indulged, is exactly that: a charming, witty, and often poignant wander through twelve months of Stanley Tucci’s life, plate by plate. From stracciatella in Rome to barbecued steaks with actor friends, marinara sauce between rehearsals, and even duck à l'orange cooked by singing Carmelite nuns (because of course). It’s about family, memory, the passage of time, and the sheer joy (and occasional infuriation) of food. Especially poignant, I thought, given his past battle with oral cancer and losing his taste.
"It’s a celebration of connection!" Brenda declared. "Food as the ultimate expression of love and family! When he talks about making meatballs with his mother and son? Sublime."
The Elephant in the Room (Or Was It a First-Class Airline Meal?)
But then, the conversation took a turn. A rather sharp, opinionated turn, mostly driven by Chad, but with murmurs of agreement from others.
"Okay, can we talk about the elitism?" Chad began, leaning forward. "He complains about airline food. Airline food! We’re supposed to feel sorry for him? The man is clearly flying first or business class!"
Chloe chimed in, "Exactly! I flew business class once – my husband saved up for years for our anniversary – and the food was incredible. Champagne! Actual cutlery! It was the most amazing meal I’d had in ages. For him to sniff at it… it just felt a bit out of touch for us normal folk here in small-town Australia."
This resonated. A lot. The discussion quickly veered into his new cookware range with Williams Sonoma. "Have you seen the prices?" Valerie exclaimed. "A single saucepan costs more than my weekly grocery bill! And that luggage collaboration? For people like us, that’s a down payment on a car, not a suitcase!"
Jenny, ever the pragmatist, added, "While I appreciate his passion for quality, one must consider the socio-economic context. What’s accessible or 'essential' for him is a luxury beyond reach for many. As an English teacher, I see how this perceived disconnect might alienate some readers."
Even I had to admit, as much as I adored the book, those parts made me wince a little. It’s one thing to appreciate good food; it’s another to seem oblivious to the fact that your "everyday" is someone else’s wildest dream.
And Then Reginald Weighed In: Or, Why "Pasta, Celebrity, Repeat" Does Not a Compelling Chronicle Make
Reginald, who had been looking increasingly pained as the positive comments trickled out, finally let out a sigh that seemed to carry the weight of all the overcooked pasta in the world. "Frankly," he began, his voice dripping with a weariness usually reserved for poorly structured fantasy novels, "I found the entire exercise utterly… tedious."
He paused for dramatic effect, ensuring all eyes were on him. "It was an interminable litany of pasta," he declared, "punctuated by yet more pasta, interspersed with the rather pedestrian recitation of encounters with various luminaries. 'I dined with Mr. Ford here,' 'Mr. Firth shared an amusing anecdote there,' 'My brother-in-law, Mr. Krasinski, opined thusly,' 'My wife's sister, Ms. Blunt, accompanied me thither.' Then it was on to Mr. Downey Jr., Mr. Ritchie... It became a monotonous cycle: celebrity, carbohydrate, repeat ad nauseam!" He gave a dismissive wave of his hand. "One might surmise the incessant name-dropping was a desperate attempt to inject some semblance of vicarious glamour into what was, fundamentally, a rather dull diary of digestion!"
Yes, Reginald hated Stanley Tucci's book, not for its perceived elitism as much as for its perceived boredom and what he considered blatant showing off.
Okay, fair, Reg, I thought, it was a lot of pasta. And yes, a lot of famous names. Aloud, I offered, a little defensively because, hey, it was my pick, "Well, I suppose when your brother-in-law is John Krasinski and your friends are Colin Firth, they're bound to pop up in your diary, right? It's a bit different from us name-dropping the mayor because we saw him at the bakery. Those are his peers, his family, his work colleagues. It's just... his life."
Reginald merely sniffed, unconvinced, and muttered something about "the relentless mundanity of celebrity." You just can't win with some people. Especially when that someone is Reginald and the book isn't about dragons.
My Spaghetti con Tonno Disaster (And Other Culinary Adventures)
This seemed like a good time to share my own Tucci culinary experience. "Well," I confessed, "inspired by the book, I tried his famous Spaghetti con Tonno. You know, the one everyone raves about?"
Faces looked expectant.
"It was… a disaster," I admitted. "My husband and I loathe cooked tuna, it turns out. He took one bite and said, 'Please, never make that again. Ever.' So much for my Tucci transformation."
Brenda gasped. "But it’s iconic! Are you sure you used high-quality imported Italian tuna packed in olive oil? And fresh parsley? The details are crucial!"
"Actually," Chloe piped up, "my friend made it for her new boyfriend, and he said it was the best pasta he’d ever eaten! So, maybe it’s just your tuna trauma, Recapper?"
Probably. But it did lead to a fun tangent about everyone’s biggest cooking fails and successes, with Gary promising to try and recreate a non-tuna Tucci-esque pasta special for the café next week. (Bless you, Gary!)
The Good, The Bad, and The "Is He Talking About Food Again?"
Despite the "elitist" debate and Reginald’s utter disdain, there was still a lot of love for the book in the room.
Valerie appreciated the writing. "He has a way with words, doesn't he? He can make a simple description of making a sandwich sound like poetry. As a writer, I admire that."
Jenny agreed. "The diary format, while perhaps lacking in 'substance' for those seeking a traditional plot, as some reviews noted, offers a unique intimacy. We see the rhythm of his year, the small moments. It’s a quiet reflection."
Mike, who still hadn’t read it, said, "Well, I did listen to him narrate 'Taste' on audiobook, and his voice is like melted butter. I bet this one sounds amazing too." (I made a mental note to actually listen to this one, even though I’d read the ebook copy. For research, of course.)
Chloe found herself relating to his descriptions of family meals. "When he talks about cooking with his kids, even the messy bits, it felt very real. Minus the Carmelite nuns, obviously."
Agnes, however, remained unconvinced. "All this fuss about food," she sighed, Fido snoring softly in her bag. "I had a very nice piece of toast for breakfast. With marmalade. It was perfectly adequate." Fido, apparently, agreed.
Eleanor, after a rather unfortunate incident involving a dropped scone and an attempt to retrieve it that revealed a startling lack of hosiery, declared, "If Stanley Tucci had a few good cats, he wouldn't be so worried about what was for dinner. Cats are very grounding. And they don't complain about airline food, just the quality of the salmon."
Final Course: Our Verdict on "What I Ate In One Year"
So, where did we land? Predictably, all over the culinary map.
I, your humble recapper, despite the tuna incident and acknowledging the valid points about perceived elitism, still adored the book. It made me hungry, happy, and determined to perfect my Negroni. I’m about 90% done now, and I’ll probably finish it by Christmas.
Brenda is already planning a Tucci-themed dinner party. Chad is probably writing a strongly worded letter to Williams-Sonoma about their pricing strategy. Reginald has likely vowed to only read epic fantasy for the next six months to cleanse his palate of "gastronomic narcissism." And Agnes is no doubt looking forward to her next piece of perfectly adequate toast.
As for the rest of us? We left "The Daily Grind" a little hungrier, a little more opinionated, and definitely entertained. And that, my friends, is the magic of book club.
A Little Note From Your Humble Recapper, Again…
Just a reminder, all names and the café name have been lovingly altered
to protect the fabulous and the occasionally flustered. If you recognize
yourself in any of these descriptions, wear your anonymous notoriety with
pride! (And Gary, if you’re reading this, I’ll take that Tucci-inspired
pasta special any day. Just, you know—hold the tuna.)
Let’s Dig In!
So, what are your thoughts? Did you read "What I Ate In One Year"? Did Stanley Tucci charm your socks off, or did you find him a bit much? And most importantly, have you ever had a cookbook recipe go spectacularly wrong? Dish the details in the comments! I’m always hungry for more stories.
And hey, if you liked this recap, let me know on Facebook, via email, or through my newsletter! This was a particularly fun one to write, and I’m always up for more bookish banter.
No comments:
Post a Comment